***Spoiler Alerts***
Where do I even begin?
This is the first time in recent memories I watched a TV show before reading the book. I love books, I do. I am really hard to please when it comes to movies/TV shows based on novels. I am one of those people in the “but the books are better” camp.
I don’t dislike the movies/TV shows just because the books are better, I am saying books provide more information on characters, story-lines, there’s just so much more for the readers to chew on.
When I was a kid and learning English as my second language, I used to think if I don’t understand meanings of the verbs or nouns that are used to describe the surroundings and environment of the characters, I can wait for the movie or TV show, then flip to the page, and voila ! the screen says it all. Boy was I ever wrong. It wasn’t until Harry Potter the first movie circa 2001 that I realized a movie or TV show doesn’t jump out of the book verbatim, and it also doesn’t follow every description. (What a huge disappointment right?)
I enjoy comparing fictions and their movies, TV shows based on them. I love compare and contrast.
I love being able to tell what scenes are from the books and what scenes are not. I love being about to tell the differences. It’s like playing a game of can you spot the differences?
Advantages of not reading the book first
Faces
So reading A Game of Thrones was definitely a whole new experience for me, and what a ride it was, why? The advantages of watching entire season 1 before reading the book.
I was reading the fictional characters with the real actors and actresses in mind!
Eddard Stark had Sean Bean’s face; Tyrion Lannister hasdPeter Dinklage’s face, Jon Snow had Kit Harington’s face, Arya Stark had Maisie Williams’ face.
And even characters without their own chapters, I still read them with their real life actors and actresses, such as Lena Headey’s Cersei Lannister, Sophie Turner’s Sansa Stark, Mark Addy’s Robert Baratheon.
Had I not watched season 1 prior, I would have seen blank faces when reading the characters. When I was reading Harry Potter Book 1-4, I was drawing blank faces, starting the fifth book I think, I started seeing Daniel Radcliffe, Rupert Grint and Emma Watson. (Am I the only one?)
I thought reading the characters with real actors and actresses faces made the reading more exciting. It felt like I ALREADY KNEW THEM or brought me a degree closer to their fictional character counterparts.
I don’t know if this is a good thing or not, it does take away the readers’ imaginations, but at the same time, you get one of those, “oh I remember this from the show! Peter Dinklage plays this part so well!”, which brings me to my second point.
The characters come to life!!!
Especially Peter’s Dinklage’s Tyrion Lannister. Dinklage won the 2011 Emmy award for Best Supporting Actor category, and I say he deserved it. In my opinion, TV Tyrion is better than Book Tyrion, all because of Dinklage’s superb acting.
If I have to pick 3 favorite characters; Eddard Stark, Tyrion Lannister and Arrya Stark. I have to admit the choices are picked based on the real life actors and actress, their acting and fictional character’s personalities.
Eddard Stark is the hero, the man that every boy wants to be. He is a lord, owns a castle, has a lovely wife, has five kids and command thousands of bannermen. He also helped his best pal to win the king’s crown who appointed him the ‘Hand of the King’ (second most powerful position in the kingdom). Consider him a CEO.
Tyrion, what’s not to like, Dinklage makes him a character that you either love or hate, makes the viewers always guessing is he good or is he bad. Tyrion easily racks up all the funniest lines in the story.
Arya Stark, she’s definitely ahead of her time, she’s the poster girl for modern day feminism. She wants to play with swords, she doesn’t want to become a lady like her sister Sansa Stark.
If there is one part that Arya Stark is better than the book; it’s the scenes between her and the dancing master teaching her how to sword fight. More scenes and dialogues were created than the book, and the dancing master is portrayed as a wisdom teacher teaching Arya about life, death, fear and fighting.
One of the dialogues that wasn’t in the book:
Dancing Master: “what do we say to god of death?”
Arya: “not today.”
If you watched the show, you would know how touching the scene was.
Name pronunciations
If I hadn’t watched the show first, I would have pronounced in my head (because I read in silent):
Arya as r-ya (on the show, I misheard it as Ion)
Joffrey as Jeffrey
Daenerys as Danny
Eddard as Edward
Targaryen as tar
Baratheon as barth
What I mean is, I WILL MAKE UP SOME SOUNDS in my head to replace the I-don’t-know-how-to-pronounce-this-name-but-too-embrassed-to-ask.
The reading pace flew smoothly, because I could pronounce the character’s names accurately, thanks to real life actors and actresses saying the names.
More Epic!
I want to add there are two scenes from the book that felt more epic to me because of the way they were filmed on the show.
P. 782-784,
Lord Commander asked Jon Snow “Are you a brother of the Night’s Watch…or only a bastard boy who wants to play at war?”
Jon Snow: “I am…yours, my lord. Your man. I swear I it. I will not run again.”
Watching those scenes on episode 10, I felt my adrenaline rushing, why? The SOUND EDITING, the SOUND MIXING, the VISUAL EFFECTS (props and costumes), and most importantly
the VOICE OVER, the scene had Kit Harignton as Jon Snow on a horse staring at the gate of THE WALL, WITH lord commander’s question as voice over. The scene didn’t even have Jon Snow answered, only riding out of the gate.
A picture is worth a thousand words eh.
P. 794-797,
When all the bannermen laid their swords at Robb Stark’s feet, repeatedly chanting “The King in the North”.
Again, the sound editing, the sound mixing, visual effects made the scene really epic.
When I was reading these pages, my memory immediately went back to those scenes, COPY AND PASTE them onto the words on the pages. EPIC.
Book 2
I wish season 1 had more than 10 episodes. I wish there were 24 episodes!! There’s so much more they could have scripted into the HBO series.
As much as I want to start on book 2 A Clash of Kings, I know I will get addicted, so I need to make sure my timetable is free for a week, which is pretty hard to do. My goal is to finish A Clash of Kings, A Storm of Swords, and A Feast for Crows before season 2 premier. Fingers crossed.